The question that overwhelms or stresses you after you or a loved one is apprehended is how you will secure their release and move on with your life pending the trial. The criminal justice system offers you two main pretrial release options: paying bail as a lump sum or purchasing a bail bond at a fraction of the total bail. Choosing between cash bail and bail bonds is a tough decision, as it has financial, personal, and legal implications. California bail is expensive, and understanding the fundamentals, associated risks, fees, and timelines is crucial in navigating the pretrial release process.
Cash Bail vs. Bail Bonds Comparison
In California, arrestees are considered innocent until proven otherwise beyond a reasonable doubt in court. Besides, it is the government’s obligation to ensure that defendants return to court for scheduled hearings upon securing pretrial freedom. Therefore, it allows defendants to exercise their rights while guaranteeing their return to court; the law requires eligible defendants to post bail. It acts as an insurance policy in case you flee the jurisdiction to evade justice.
Here is how bail works. You or another party deposits an asset or money with the court handling the case. The court holds the asset or funds as security for your release. The court uses the deposit as an incentive to compel you to attend court. When the case ends, you receive a refund regardless of the outcome. However, when you violate bail terms, you forfeit the deposit.
Not every defendant is eligible for bail. The court decides on your release depending on the case’s facts.
Other times, the court releases defendants on their own recognizance if they do not face offenses punishable by death and meet the following conditions:
- They do not threaten public safety
- They will be more likely to attend future court proceedings
With an OR release, you do not have to post bail for release. You just signed a note promising to return to court as arranged and to adhere to the bail terms.
If the court sets bail, you must post it to be released from police custody. Your two primary options for posting bail are:
Paying the Entire Bail Figure in Cash
You secure release on cash bail when you pay the set amount in full directly to the court or the law enforcement agency that made the arrest. Courts have varying policies regarding cash bail payments. You can pay using cash, a money order, a cashier’s check, a traveler’s check, or a personal check. The primary advantage of using cash bail for pretrial release is that if you comply with the court’s terms, you receive a refund, although not in full, as the court deducts administrative costs when making the refund.
Another feature of cash bail is that it involves the defendant, their family, and the court. The defendant needs the family because it is difficult to raise money from behind bars.
Additionally, no collateral is required to guarantee the release. The money acts as insurance. However, the disadvantage of this option is that you place large sums of money at risk, because if you jump bail or contravene other release terms, you could forfeit the money.
Bail Bonds
Not many defendants in California can afford cash bail, as the amounts can run into tens or hundreds of thousands of dollars. If you cannot afford cash bail, you risk pretrial detention until the trial, meaning you cannot move on with your life. Fortunately, you can use a bail bond to secure release. Bail bonds are the most commonly utilized pretrial release options because they are affordable.
A bail bond is a contract between the defendant, a cosigner (usually a trusted family member), the court, and a bail bonds firm. The bail bondsman posts a surety bond with the court, assuming responsibility for your future court appearances. In return, you, the cosigner, pay the bail bondsman a nonrefundable fee, typically 10% of the total bail, for the services offered.
Depending on the case’s facts, the bail bondsman can demand collateral from your cosigner to secure the surety bond against the possible risk of jumping bail. So, when you jump bail, you lose the premium you paid and the collateral, as the company sells them to recoup its losses after the bail bond forfeiture.
If you do not have money for cash bail or do not want to tie hefty amounts to a possible risk of forfeiture, bail bonds are an affordable way of exiting custody. You only require a fraction of the total bail to regain freedom, unlike cash bail, where you must deposit the full amount.
The Financial Risks of Paying Full Bail
Even when you have money readily available to pay cash bail, you must evaluate the risk or consequences it will have on you or your cosigner’s finances.
- Massive Cash Outlay
You must have immediate access to liquid funds to minimize your stay in jail. And because you cannot raise the money from detention, your family will assume the responsibility of consolidating the funds. If you do not have the funds lying idle in a bank account, your loved ones must liquidate their savings, take out loans, or sell property to raise the money. Once they deposit the funds with the court’s clerk, they cannot access them for months or years, depending on the duration of the case. Therefore, even after you leave jail, you have to find other sources of income to pay attorney fees, bills, and other expenses, leading to severe financial strain for you and your family.
- The Risk of Bail Forfeiture
Similarly, there is a risk of forfeiture, as a refund hinges on your compliance with the court’s terms. If you skip court without informing the court in advance or for a justifiable reason, the court could order a forfeiture of the full amount. So, when you have a justifiable reason to skip court, such as a medical emergency, you must notify your defense attorney or the court in advance; otherwise, you risk incurring colossal financial losses.
- Cash Bail is Not Punishment for Your Crime
The money you pay is not punishment for your offense. Instead, it is a guarantee of returning to court. Therefore, your case will continue after release, and if you are convicted, you will face the necessary legal penalties. A refund is issued upon the successful conclusion of the case. However, it is not guaranteed, as the court can redirect the money to court-ordered payments and victim restitution.
Cash bail has attracted a lot of criticism in recent years because it disadvantages people of color and low-income earners, who are the majority of defendants in California. These individuals are forced to remain in pretrial detention solely because they cannot afford the required bail, not because they are ineligible. The system seems to favor the wealthy, which is why there are calls for bail reform.
Refund Timelines in California Courts
The time it takes the court to refund your bail depends on the bail option.
Cash Bail Refunds
Typically, the refund is made to the depositor or the party that posted the bail on your behalf. This is usually the party that signed the money order, cashier’s, banker’s, or traveler’s check to pay bail.
When you pay bail in cash, and you comply with the court terms, you will receive a refund via mail within 30 business days of the sentencing or exoneration order, whichever comes later. Delays in processing the refund could mean you wait 60 to 90 days for it to arrive.
The money comes via mail. If you have changed addresses before the case conclusion, inform the presiding judge or the court’s clerk of your new address. Alternatively, you can send a letter to the court to inform them of your new address if you change addresses after a deposition or exoneration order.
Bail Bond Refunds
Refunds when you use bail bonds for pretrial release are different. The bail bond premium you pay to the bail bondsman is nonrefundable, even if you are compliant with the contract terms. The premium is payment for the service the company offers, which is to take responsibility for your court appearances. So, when you go the bail bonds route, you should not expect a refund.
However, when collateral is involved, the company will release the property or asset used as collateral once the court exonerates the surety bond. When you obey court terms and the case ends, the court exonerates the bond deposited on your behalf, eliminating the bail bondsman’s obligation to pay you bail as the case has ended. Once the company is released from this obligation, it returns the collateral to the cosigner.
The company will not release the collateral even after the case ends if you have not paid the premiums. This is usually the case when you cannot afford the premium in full. Even a fraction of the total bail premium can be expensive for many defendants to afford upfront. Some bail bondsmen provide defendants with flexible repayment plans, which involve the payment of a deposit and the balance in installments after the defendant is released. Therefore, when you default on the payment of the premium, the company can hold the collateral even after the court exonerates the bail bond until the agreed-upon premium is fully paid.
When Bail Bonds are the Smarter Option
A bail bond is a more financially savvy option for getting out of custody, despite the nonrefundable premium. The reasons it is a smarter option include:
- You Preserve Money for Future Use
One of the primary reasons you should go for bail bonds to secure release is that you preserve liquid assets. This means that when you leave jail, you will have access to the funds necessary to enlist the services of the best criminal defense attorney and cater to your living costs. You only need 10% to access bail bond services, leaving the rest for future use.
- It is An Affordable Option When Bail is Exorbitant
Severe charges, such as felonies, attract hefty bail amounts. The judge has the discretion to revise upwards the bail figure provided in the schedule. If your bail is excessive, it can be difficult to consolidate the funds required to post cash bail. This leaves you with bail bonds as a quick and affordable option. All you need to do is raise a fraction of the bail amount to leave detention. If you cannot afford the premium, you can negotiate a flexible repayment plan, further lowering the initial cost of bail.
- Access to Expert Guidance
Experienced bail bondsmen understand the criminal justice system and can streamline the release process. When you contact them, they will explain the process and requirements and help you fill out the application forms. If you have questions about the process, these experts are best positioned to answer them.
Additionally, your bail bondsman will guide you post-release to ensure you remember the bail conditions and comply with them to avoid forfeiture. A forfeiture is a loss for you and the company. So, they are invested in ensuring compliance and will be on your side until the court issues a verdict.
- Reduced Financial Scrutiny
You can use bail bonds to secure your release after arrest and avoid financial scrutiny if you are charged with a drug crime or embezzlement. The court knows the sources of funds used by licensed bail bondsmen are legitimate and will not question their use for bail.
However, when you use cash bail, you risk having your bail being categorized as suspicious. The police, judge, or prosecutor can hold your cash bail until a special hearing is held if they suspect the funds were feloniously obtained. When the funds are put on hold, you must provide documents to prove they are legitimate, attracting public scrutiny into your personal life.
Suspicious bail could also mean a longer stay in jail, since the hearing is held after a few days. Therefore, even when liquid money is available for cash bail, you should post bail through an accredited bail bondsman. The company will deposit a bond for you, helping you maintain a low profile.
Find a Seasoned Bail Bondsman Near Me
When your options for securing bail are limited to paying cash or using bail bonds, choosing the best option can be challenging. You will have several questions about the financial risks involved and whether the court will return your money. The decision depends on your financial position. Before making a decision, consult a bail bondsman to explain your options, benefits, and risks to make the right choice.
At Balboa Bail Bonds, we will provide clarity and help you navigate this complex decision. Call us today at 619-760-2222 for a zero-obligation consultation in California.
Tags: Is It Better to Pay Bail or Use a Bail Bond in California?